KREMLIN INFORMATION CAMPAIGN IN THE BALTIC STATES DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC ESCALATION OF SPRING 2020

The authors examine pro-Russian media outlets during the escalation of COVID-19 
pandemics in Spring 2020 (March–May). Strategic narratives constructed and disseminated 
by the Russian Federation for the Baltic states (Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania) may emphasize: 
political and economic motives related to the policies of governments of the Baltic states; 
status-related motives to disrupt the international system and Western-led political institutions 
through the Baltic states; conflictual motives indicating opposing identities between Russian 
and Baltic nations, which have often emphasized the Russophobic context of the Baltic 
identity-building. These strategic narratives are part of Moscow’s strategy that aim is to 
destroy the unity of West and to increase ideological fragmentation in the European Union. 
Therefore, Baltic states have become an important target of influence operations conducted 
by the Russian Federation because of their geopolitical location and strategic importance. 

Full text (pdf)

1. Adams, M., Irrefutable: The coronavirus was engineered by scientists in a lab using well documented genetic engineering vectors that leave behind a “fin-gerprint”, “NaturalNews.com”, 3.02.2020 [Access: 14.04.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.naturalnews.com/2020-02-03-the-coronavirus-was-engineered-by-scientists-in-a-lab.html.
2. Altheide, D.L. (2002). Creating Fear: News and the Construction of Crisis. Hawthorne, NY: De Gruyter.
3. Antoniades, A., O’Loughlin, B., Miskimmon, A. (2010). Great power politics and strategic narratives. “Working paper No. 7”, The Centre for Global Political Economy. Falmer: University of Sussex.
4. Barnes, J.E., Rosenberg, M., Wong, E., As Virus Spreads, China and Russia See Openings for Disinformation. “New York Times”, 28.3.2020 [Access: 27.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/28/us/politics/china-russia-coronavirus-disinformation.html?action=click&module=RelatedLinks&pgtype=Article.
5. Broad, W.J., Putin’s Long War Against American Science. “New York Times”, 13.04.2020 [Access: 17.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/13/science/putin-russia-disinformation-health-coronavirus.html.
6. Darczewska, J., Żochowski, P. (2015). Russophobia in the Kremlin’s Strategy. A Weapon of Mass Destruction. “Point of View”, 56. Warsaw: Centre of East European Studies.
7. Director of National Intelligence. 2017. Background to “Assessing Russian Activities and Intentions in Recent US Elections”: The Analytic Process and Cyber Incident Attribution. Washington DC, January 6. Intelligence Community Assessment. [Access: 6.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/ICA_2017_01.pdf.
8. Einmann, A., Kremli propagandasõnum: maskid Eestisse on Venemaa humanitaarabi, “Postimees”, 6.4.2020 [Access: 27.04.2020]. Access on the internet:https://www.postimees.ee/6943089/kremli-propagandasonum-maskid-eestisse-on-venemaa-humanitaarabi.
9. Err.ee, 2019 = Sputnik peatas Eestis tegevuse, Err.ee, 31.12.2019 [Access: 23.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.err.ee/1019225/sputnik-peatas-eestis-tegevuse.
10. Err.ee, 2020 = Ajaleht: 80 protsenti Vene sõjaväe abist Itaaliale osutus kasutuks. 2020, „Err.ee“, 26.3.2020 [Access: 27.04.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.err.ee/1068903/ajaleht-80-protsenti-vene-sojavae-abist-itaaliale-osutus-kasutuks.
11. Feklyunina, V. (2013). Constructing Russophobia. [In:] Taras, R. (ed.) Russia’s Identity in International Relations: Images, Perceptions, Misperceptions, London: Routledge.
12. Franke, U. (2015). War by non-military means: Understanding Russian information warfare, Stockholm: Totalförsvarets forskningsinstitut.
13. Galston, W. A., The Populist Challenge to Liberal Democracy. “Journal of Democracy,” 29(2) (2018), p. 5−19 [Access: 10.11.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.journalofdemocracy.org/articles/the-populist-challenge-to-liberal-democracy/.
14. Giuffrida, A., Roth, A., Moscow's motives questioned over coronavirus aid shipment to Italy, “The Guardian”, 27.4.2020 [Access: 21.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/27/moscow-motives-questioned-over-coronavirus-aid-shipment-to-italy.
15. Hinck, R.S., Kluver, R., Cooley, S. (2018). Russia re-envisions the world: strategic narratives in Russian broadcast and news media during 2015. “Russian Journal of Communication”, 10(1).
16. B. Heap B., Krauel, S., Althuis, J. (eds.) (2019). Hybrid Threats: A Strategic Communications Perspectiv. Riga: NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence.
17. Howard, P.N., Ganesh, B., Liotsiou, D., Kelly, J., François, C. The IRA, Social Media and Political Polarization in the United States, 2012−2018. “Working Paper”, 2018/2 [Access: 11.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://comprop.oii.ox.ac.uk/research/ira-political-polarization/.
18. Jantunen, S. (2018). Infosõda, Tlk Tuule Meri. Tallinn: Kultuurileht.
19. Kaitsepolitsei aastaraamat 2015. Koostanud H. Puusepp, Tallinn: Iloprint, 2015 [Access: 10.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.kapo.ee/sites/default/files/public/content_page/aastaraamat-2015.pdf.
20. Karlsen, G.H. (2019. Divide and rule: ten lessons about Russian political influence activities in Europe. “Palgrave Communication” 5(19).
21. Kracauer, S. (1953). The Challenge of Qualitative Content Analysis. “The Public Opinion Quarterly”, Vol. 16, No. 4.
22. Kuckartz, U. (2014). Qualitative Text Analysis: A Guide to Methods. Practice & Using Software. London: Sage Publications.
23. Kuhrt, N., Feklyunina, V. (eds.) (2017). Assessing Russia's power: A report. King's College London and Newcastle University.
24. Laruelle, M., Radvanyi, J. (2018). Understanding Russia: The Challenges of Transformation. Rowman and Littlefield Publishers.
25. Latvijas Radio, Stratcom director: China and Russia top Covid-19 disinformation sources, “Latvijas Radio”, 9.4.2020 [Access: 24.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://eng.lsm.lv/article/society/defense/stratcom-director-china-and-russia-top-covid-19-disinformation-sources.a355222/?fbclid=IwAR0D0JzY_6e11aVB1098BGs897O3SQfM16ISmgWoxm8jisKNQVTXWfwpTBU
26. Lebow, R.N. (2010). The Past and Future of War, “International Relations”, 24(3).
27. Lucas, E., Pomerantsev, P. (2016). Winning the Information War: Techniques and Counter-strategies to Russian Propaganda in Central and Eastern Europe. CEPA Report: Washington DC.
28. Makarychev, A., Sazonov, V. (2019). Populisms, popular geopolitics and the politics of belonging in Estonia. “European Politics and Society”, 20(4).
29. Miskimmon, A., O'Loughlin, B., Roselle, L., (eds.) (2018). Forging the World. Strategic Narratives and International Relations, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
30. Mäkinen, S. (2011). Surkovian Narrative on the Future of Russia: Making Russia a World Leader. “Journal of Communist Studies and Transition Politics”, 27:2.
31. Mölder, H. (2016). The War of Narratives – Putin’s Challenge to International Security Governance in Ukraine. “Sõjateadlane”, 2.
32. Mölder, H., Sazonov, V. (2018). Information Warfare as the Hobbesian concept of Modern Times – Principles, Techniques and Tools of Russian Information Operations in Donbass. “Journal of Slavic Military Studies”, 31(3).
33. Mölder, H., Sazonov, V. (2019). The Impact of Russian Anti-Western Conspiracy Theories on the Status-related Conflict in Ukraine: The Case of Flight MH17. “Baltic Journal of European Studies”, 9(3).
34. Mölder, H., Sazonov, V. (2020). Venemaa strateegilised narratiivid Balti riikidele suunatud mõjutustegevuses COVID-19 kriisi ajal. “Sõjateadlane”, 14.
35. Orttung, R.W., Nelson, E. (2018). Russia Today’s strategy and effectiveness on YouTube. “Post Soviet Affairs”, 35(2) [Access: 17.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/1060586X.2018.1531650?journalCode=rpsa20.
36. Parts, M. Paet: Euroopa sulgemise vigadest on vaja tulevikus õppida. “Postimees”, 8.5.2020 [Access: 16.09.2020]. Access on the internet: https://maailm.postimees.ee/6968855/paet-euroopa-sulgemise-vigadest-on-vaja-tulevikus-oppida.
37. Propastop, 2018 = Uuriv ajakirjandus valgustab Kremli propagandamasina siseelu. “Propastop” 03.09.2018 [Access: 16.09.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.propastop.org/2018/09/03/4187/.
38. Prothero, M., Russia sent Italy a military convoy of medical supplies to help with the coronavirus outbreak, Italy said it was useless and accused them of a PR stunt. “Business Insider”, 26.3.2020 [Access: 11.04.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-italy-russia-military-convoy-supplies-useless-pr-stunt-2020-3.
39. Radin, A. (2017). Hybrid Warfare in the Baltics: Threats and Potential Responses. Santa Monica: Rand Corporation.
40. Renz, B. (2016). Russia and ‘hybrid warfare’. “Contemporary Politics”, Vol. 22, Issue 3.
41. Roselle, L., Miskimmon, A, O'Loughlin, B. (2013). Strategic Narratives: Communication Power and the New World Order, Routledge.
42. Rough, P. How China is Exploiting the Coronavirus to Weaken Democracies, “Foreign Policy”, 25.3.2020 [Access: 29.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/03/25/china-coronavirus-propaganda-weakens-western- democracies/?utm_source=PostUp&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=20502&utm_term=Editor&fbclid=IwAR20YdPlmmmH8JA8xvH9VvDRaGqKq73-2imqjtg3-jK2QXzMNidQS5Igpb0#39;s%20Picks%20OC&?tpcc=20502.
43. Sakwa, R. (2007). Vladimir Putin and Russian Foreign Policy towards the West: Towards a New Realism [in:] Robertson, L., Gower, J., Timmins, G. (eds.). Russia and Europe in the Twenty-First Century. An Uneasy Partnership, Anthem Press.
44. Sazonov, V., Koort, E., Heinsoo, P., Paas, K. (2020). Introduction of Hybrid Threats of Internal Security. Tallinn: Sisekaitseakadeemia [Access: 04.12.20202]. Access on the internet: https://digiriiul.sisekaitse.ee/bitstream/handle/123456789/2576/2020%2010%20Sisejulgeoleku%20h%C3%BCbriidohtude%20tutvustamine%20ENG%20A4_web.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.
45. Spriņģe, I., How Russian Propaganda Becomes Even Nastier in Baltic News. “Re:Baltica”, 29.03.2018 [Access: 24.04.2020]. Access on the internet: https://en.rebaltica.lv/2017/03/how-russian-propaganda-becomeseven-nastier-in-baltic-news/.
46. Surkov, V. (2008). Russian political culture: The view from utopia. “Russian Social Science Review”, 49(6).
47. Szostek, J. (2017). The Power and Limits of Russia’s Strategic Narrative in Ukraine: The Role of Linkage.“Perspectives on Politics”, 15(2).
48. Tass.com, 2020 = Several EU countries cannot ask for Russia’s help because of their ‘big brothers’ – Lavrov, “TASS Russian News agency”, 26.4.2020 [Access: 7.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://tass.com/politics/1149715.
49. The Moscow Times, 2020 = Russia Is a ‘Distinct Civilization,’ Putin Says. “The Moscow Times”, 18.5.2020 [Access: 29.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2020/05/18/russia-is-a-distinct-civilization-putin-says-a70295.
50. van Herpen, M. (2016). Putin’s Propaganda Machine. Soft Power and Russian Foreign Policy. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.
51. Ventsel, A., Madisson, M.-L., Hansson, S, Sazonov, V. (2018). Hirmu mehhanismid strateegilistes narratiivudes Õppuse Zapad 2017 näitel. “Sõjateadlane”, 8.
52. Ventsel, A, Hansson, S., Sazonov, V. (2019). Discourse of fear in strategic narratives: The case of Russia’s Zapad war games. “Media, War & Conflict”.
53. World Health Organization, Coronavirus [Access: 18.04.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.who.int/health-topics/coronavirus.
54. Yablokov, I. (2018). Fortress Russia. Conspiracy Theories in post-Soviet Russia, Cambridge: Polity Press.

THE SAMPLE FOR CONTENT ANALYSIS

1. Avva, 2020 = Авва, В., Возращение Латвии к Росcии: коронавирус расставляет все по своим местам. “RuBaltic.ru”, 24.3.2020 [Access: 20.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.rubaltic.ru/article/ekonomika-i-biznes/24032020-vozvrashchenie-latvii-k-rossii-koronavirus-rasstavlyaet-vse-po-svoim-mestam/.
2. Armazanova 2020 = Армазанова, Т., Коронавирус разделяет Евросоюз, “Inosmi.ru”, 31.3.2020 [Access: 11.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://inosmi.ru/politic/20200331/247165844.html.
3. Baltnews.ee, 2020 = Развал Евросоюза – чьи-то мечты или неизбежное продолжение пандемии коронавируса? “Baltnews.ee”, 15.5.2020 [Access: 21.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://baltnews.ee/mir_novosti/20200515/1018553399/Razval-Evrosoyuza--chi-to-mechty-ili-neizbezhnoe-prodolzhenie-pandemii-koronavirusa.html.
4. Baburin, 2020 = Бабурин, Р., Даже во время эпидемии страны Балтии верны русофобии, “Ритм Евразии”, 6.4.2020 [Access: 11.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.ritmeurasia.org/news--2020-04-06--dazhe-vo-vremja-epidemii-strany-baltiiverny-rusofobii-48323.
5. Baranmov, Afonina, 2020 = Баранов, А.; Афонина, Е, Прибалтийская русофобия и её истоки – Программа ≪Национальный вопрос≫, “Радио ≪Комсомольская правда≫”, 8.4.2016 [Access: 21.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https:// www.kp.ru/radio/26511/3531281/.
6. Buchanan, 2020 = Бьюкенен, П., The American Conservative (США): какова будет цена победы в войне с коронавирусом. “Inosmi.ru”, 16.4.2020 [Access: 20.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://inosmi.ru/politic/20200416/247273254.html.
7. Inosmi.ru, 2020 = Дневник (Болгария): если коронавирус уничтожит еврозону, виноватой будет «бережливая четверка», “Inosmi.ru”, 2.4.2020 [Access: 11.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://inosmi.ru/politic/20200402/247180668.html.
8. Ivanov, 2020a = Иванов, E., Страх и ненависть пандемии. Литва расплачивается за чужие ошибки, “Baltnews”, 1.4.2020 [Access: 13.04.2020]. Access on the internet:  https://baltnews.lt/mir_novosti_/20200401/1019845558/Strakh-i-nenavistpandemii-Litva-rasplachivaetsya-za-chuzhie-oshibki.html.
9. Ivanov, 2020b = Иванов, A., Чума на три прибалтийские хаты – со всех вокзалов поезда везут домой реэмигрантов, “Фонд стратегической культуры”, 27.4.2020 [Access: 17.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://www.fondsk.ru/news/2020/04/27/chuma-na-tri-pribaltijskie-haty-vezutdomoj-reemigrantov-50733.html.
10. Krugley, 2020 = Круглей, И., Коронавирус ≪схлопнул≫ Шенген: куда теперь податься прибалтийским гастарбайтерам, “Baltnews”, 1.4.2020 [Access: 22.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://lv.baltnews.com/ekonomika_online_novosti/20200401/1023795618/Koronavirus-skhlopnul-Shengen-kuda-teper-podatsyapribaltiyskim-gastarbayteram.html.
11. Nikolaeyv, 2020 = Николаев, Н., Коронавирус головного мозга: русофобов Эстонии Оскорбила помощь Москвы, “RadioSputnik”, 11.4.2020 [Access: 13.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://radiosputnik.ria.ru/20200411/1569849152.html.
12. Pyh, 2020 = Пых, О., Коронавирус в Латвии: русские и латыши по-прежнему говорят на разных языках, и это хорошо, “Sputniknews”, 12.4.2020 [Access: 9.04.2020]. Access on the internet: https://lv.sputniknews.ru/columnists/20200412/13545838/Koronavirus-v-Latvii-russkie-i-latyshi-po-prezhnemugovoryat-na-raznykh-yazykakh-i-eto-khorosho.html.
13. Petrinis, 2020 = Пятринис, А., Захват ЕС. Как коронавирус убил единую Европу и показал, кто есть кто, “Sputniknews”, 21.3.2020 [Access: 22.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://lt.sputniknews.ru/columnists/20200321/11659770/ Zakhvat-ES-Kak-koronavirus-ubil-edinuyu-Evropu-i-pokazal-kto-est-kto.html.
14. RuBaltic.ru, 2020 = ЕС – не Европа, а немцы, итальянцы и поляки»: американский эксперт высказался о будущем континента после пандемии, “RuBaltic.ru”, 30.4.2020. [Access: 21.05.2020]. Access on the internet:  https://www.rubaltic.ru/news/30042020-es-ne-evropa-a-nemtsy-italyantsy-i-polyakiamerikanskiy-ekspert-vyskazalsya-o-budushchem-kontinenta-/.
15. Vinnikov, 2020 = Винников, А. Коронавирус подарил Прибалтике новый повод для русофобии, „Взгляд. Деловая Газета”, 7.4.2020 [Access: 13.05.2020]. Access on the internet: https://vz.ru/world/2020/4/7/1032712.html.